Shop More Submit  Join Login

Comments


:iconmsteeq:
msteeq Featured By Owner Mar 22, 2014
nice cards.
Reply
:iconjpthemarine:
JPthemarine Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012
Agree with most of the critics here about things being OP, but the idea of them being what they are(mana cost, types, and whathnots) is very nice. thinking the same idea but only proxining out pics from real cards to make a funny deck with them.
Reply
:iconjpthemarine:
JPthemarine Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012
Agree with most of the critics here about things being OP, but the idea of them being what they are(mana cost, types, and whathnots) is very nice. thinking the same idea but only proxining out pics from real cards to make a funny deck with them.
Reply
:iconderaza360:
DeRaza360 Featured By Owner Oct 14, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Aye, a bit unbalanced in my opinion. The art style shifts and changes and it looks as if though it wasn't tested. Also, a lack of land pieces means I can't make a deck. Can be improved.

However, good work so far.
Reply
:icon8kiba9:
8Kiba9 Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012
are you still making more?^^
Reply
:iconneongecko06:
neongecko06 Featured By Owner Jun 12, 2012
Magic: The Gathering of Friends.
Reply
:iconmanasparks:
ManaSparks Featured By Owner May 22, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
I've made some cards too! Wanna know some of them?
Reply
:iconjionunez:
Jionunez Featured By Owner Apr 22, 2012
Making a White-Red Pony deck
Reply
:iconmtg-critic:
MTG-Critic Featured By Owner Nov 4, 2011
Hey, it's really cool that you had the motivation to make all these flavorful MLP cards! :D

I did notice, however, that most of them were either WAAAAY to overpowered (Spike (both the paladin and regular version), Pinkie's Gaze, most of the ponies) or unplayably bad (most of the planeswalkers). When designing a magic card, you have to bear in mind that is has to be balanced. A good way to do this is by comparing/contrasting it to a currently existing card that's making a big ruckus. Your most absurdly broken card is Owlowiscious; drawing cards is one of the most powerful abilities in MTG, and drawing THREE on a common creature with no drawback is absolutely ridiculous. Check out the value of this card to understand what the MTG community thinks: [link]
When you put an ability like that onto a creature, you only make it better.

Some of the cards you made I thought were actually very well-designed and balanced were Luna the Planeswalker and Fluttershy. Your Luna planeswalker is solid and fair at the four mana cost. Meanwhile, the other planeswalker cards are far too weak for their cost (especially Celestia costing 2WRUBG).

Sorry if this came off as harsh or anything. I love that you're into Magic and are exercising your imagination, so I want to help ensure that your cards are well-designed.
Reply
:iconjrk08004:
jrk08004 Featured By Owner Aug 11, 2011  Hobbyist General Artist
yay another MLTC:FiM:tG maker! (My Little Trading Card: Friendship is Magic: the Gathering). Come check out my gallery!
Reply
Add a Comment: